The debate around providing educational benefits for undocumented students -- particularly in regards to providing financial aid or in-state college tuition rates -- has been heating up over the past few months at both the state and federal level.
At the federal level, the Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors, or Dream Act, which was introduced in the U.S. House of Representatives and Senate on March 26, would allow states to charge the children of undocumented immigrants in-state tuition and provide a multi-step path to citizenship for these students. Advocates of the federal Dream Act are launching a new effort to pass the bill this year.
In order to receive the bill's benefits, undocumented students must have been in the country for five years, be 15 years old or younger at the time they entered the country and be of "good moral character." To gain permanent legal status in the country, the applicant must complete a two-year college or vocational school program, have two years toward a bachelor's or serve in the armed forces for at least two years.
Dream Act supporters say at its core the bill is about equity and fairness in dealing with undocumented students. Opponents, on the other hand, say it would reward bad behavior, fueling further waves of illegal immigration.
The Dream Act has failed in the four previous Congresses, getting as far as House approval nearly two years ago. But now, with the Obama Administration announcing plans to talk about immigration reform this year combined with a strengthened Democratic congressional majority, supporters say the bill stands a good chance of passing. As a senator, Obama was a cosponsor in 2007.
The bill continues to gain national and local support. In April, the College Board -- a nonprofit group composed of more than 5,000 member schools and other educational organizations -- announced its support of the Dream Act. In the report "Young Lives on Hold: The College Dreams of Undocumented Students," the College Board notes that the Dream Act would allow 360,000 undocumented high school graduates to attend college and legalize their immigration status. The organization also notes that the act would provide incentives for another 715,000 youngsters between the ages of 5 and 17 to finish high school and pursue post-secondary education. Every year, approximately 65,000 undocumented students graduate from high school, only 5 to 10 percent of them attend college, according to the report.
Proponents of the Dream Act also highlight its potential as an economic stimulus package. It would strengthen the economy by creating a more educated work force and it would boost overall school revenues by bringing in tuition from students who otherwise would not be able to attend college, advocates say. The College Board report underscores that not allowing undocumented students the chance to pursue higher education adds up to a significant amount of "wasted talent" that "imposes economic and emotional costs" on students themselves and on U.S. society as a whole.
Earlier this month Janet Napolitano said she supported the Dream Act as the governor of Arizona, and she supports it now -- as secretary of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security.
States as the first battleground
In 1982, the Supreme Court ruled that undocumented students could legally attend K-12 public schools. However, the decision did not address public education beyond high school. While undocumented students are permitted to attend college in most states, they are ineligible for federal financial aid, cannot legally work to pay for college, and are required to pay out-of-state tuition rates (in-state tuition tends to be two to three times less than what out-of-state students pay).
While the Dream Act is federal legislation, it will have important implications at the state level by mandating that states charge undocumented immigrants in-state tuition at public colleges and universities.
Currently states continue to be divided over providing benefits, and in many cases leave it up to individual colleges to decide. At least four states - Georgia, Oklahoma, Colorado, Arizona - prohibit undocumented students from paying in-state tuition rates. In 2008 South Carolina banned undocumented students from enrolling at any of its public colleges, and North Carolina barred them from its community colleges in 2007. Alabama also blocks undocumented students from its two-year colleges, and Virginia is considering a law to deny enrollment, reports the Associated Press.
In contrast, between 2001 and 2006, 10 states -- among them California, Kansas, and New York -- passed legislation awarding in-state tuition rates to undocumented students. Texas is currently the only Southern state to offer in-state tuition to undocumented immigrants.
A bill supporting in-state tuition was introduced this year in Arkansas, but it failed in the Senate, although the vote was closer than expected. The Progressive States Network reports that the North Carolina legislature is now reconsidering their ban since a new study found that allowing undocumented students to enroll at out-of-state levels would generate needed revenues for the state.




This Dream Act is a great opportunity for the U.S future economy. And will have more proffesionals on their workforce, and those students dont deserve to be rejected from having an education. There NOT criminals they just want to be part of society and help the U.S in many ways
I support the dream act And The Comprehenssive Immigration Reform
May 15, 2009 3:46 PM | Reply
I am for legalization of undocumented who have lived here, paid taxes, learn the language and have no criminal record. There are adults who came here as kids and have a high school degree but can proceed to college because of lack of required and qualified documents. I am for the DREAM ACT, I am all for legalizing the undocumented who came here illegal or overstayed their visas in the past 20 years. I wish people would stop sending hate messages towards the poor undocumented who are here to make a living and provide a future for their legal and illegal births in the United States. The ones who spread hatred about immigration reform, are those who are certainly not educated and are collecting medicaid and social security that the undocumented pay taxes on. Without those undocumented who pay taxes, those hatred fueled lazy people would not be able to get aid that most poverty undocumented could benefit. We are a nation of immigrants. Through out history, economy gets better with people purchasing cars, houses, create companies, provide jobs. I am for legalizaiton for undocumented immigrants. I am not concerned how the penalties will arise,but I am sure it is much more severe compared to someone who waited in line and came here thru a legal path to work here. Don’t worry, I believe the undocumented will become legal to work, but have to wait much longer for a green card, compared to those who have done the paper process the right way. I think the politicians are listening, but majority have their sight placed on their re-elections/ future/ and personal benefit, compared to the opinion of their voter. Although, the politicians are educated. Most have Masters degree in law, education, business, ect., so perhaps they will do the right thing. Close the borders (which they are); bring the undocumented out of the shadows, and the economy will thrive. History in the bible years, will portray wealth by allowing citizens of the world to come to the cities and flourish in economy, education and the arts. Many uneducated people who are unhappy, will blame the undocumented, Mexicans, oppose those undocumented who overstayed their visas such as people from China, Middle East, Europe, Canada, Australia, ensoforth. Stop picking on the poor and uneducated people who pick your crop on daily basis, or slaughter the pig that you are eating tonight. I don’t think you would slaughter 500 pigs a day would you, or clean your 5 bedroom house or mowing your maniculate 5 acre lawn? Wake up America!! Undocumented people are needed to create a wealthy economy. Look at the Reagan Years, how the economy thrived. I can’t wait for the undocumented to become legal so the economy will thrive.
Amen! God Bless and pray for immigration reform is created and that undocumented who have lived here a long time, become legal residents and get a chance to become American Citizens.
God Bless President Obama, please help those who are in limbo and love this country, to become citizens!!
May 16, 2009 2:56 AM | Reply
Not in Oklahoma Josh. God Bless Oklahoma for protecting us against people like Obama and his Liberal Congress
May 18, 2009 5:58 PM | Reply
I am for legalization of undocumented who have lived here, paid taxes, learn the language and have no criminal record. There are adults who came here as kids and have a high school degree but can proceed to college because of lack of required and qualified documents. I am for the DREAM ACT, I am all for legalizing the undocumented who came here illegal or overstayed their visas in the past 20 years.
August 2, 2009 2:10 PM | Reply
I love Obama's reforms for idealistic reasons. He reminds me of Clinton, who saw America only as strong and as opportunistic as its weakest link. Important issues like the economy are controlled by too many factors besides the President, but immigration and reforms on the issue of green card visasare issues entirely within the President's grasp.
October 7, 2009 10:16 AM | Reply
im not going anywhere else, even you gonna give me or not.
im here any way!
October 29, 2009 12:39 PM | Reply