Facing South

Are undocumented immigrants 'persons'?

When the U.S. Census counts the population of the country every 10 years, who qualifies as a person? This week, the state of Louisiana filed a lawsuit which challenges the Census' long-standing policy of counting all residents -- citizens and non-citizens -- and using those results to divide up seats in the U.S. Congress.

The lawsuit, which has broad implications for the political role of immigrants, comes after Louisiana lost a Congressional seat following the 2010 Census count. Thanks to the massive displacement after Hurricane Katrina -- the city of New Orleans lost 30% of its population between 2000 and 2010 -- Louisiana's delegation fell from seven seats to six.

During the last 10 years, every other Southern state saw growth -- in many cases fueled by new immigrants. Texas, for example, gained four Congressional seats thanks to its burgeoning population; the Census estimates two-thirds of the growth came in the Latino/Hispanic community.

New immigrants were also key to increases in size, and added Congressional seats, in Florida, Georgia and South Carolina. Nationally, about 22% of voting-age Latinos are not citizens.

In the lawsuit filed directly to the Supreme Court, Louisiana v. Bryson [pdf], Louisiana argues that the Census policy of counting non-citizens allows other states to gain clout "at the expense of states containing relatively few" undocumented immigrants, like Louisiana. Leave out the undocumented residents, Louisiana says, and it would still have seven Congressional seats.

Louisiana Attorney General Buddy Caldwell innocently says that "Louisiana's complaint simply asks the court to require the federal government to re-calculate the 2010 apportionment of U.S. House of Representatives seats based on legal residents."

If the Supreme Court ruled in Louisiana's favor, the fallout would be anything but simple. Aside from forcing 17 states to scrap their political maps on the eve of the 2012 elections, the law would fundamentally change how the Census works and immigrants are recognized in the country.

The U.S. Constitution originally said the Census should involve "counting the whole number of free persons," which the 14th Amendment changed to "counting the whole number of persons," including non-citizens.

Changing that mandate would be felt at every level of government and the economy. States and localities, which provide services like police, fire and medical treatment to undocumented residents, depend on billions in federal aid based on whole-person counts. Undocumented residents also paid $11.2 billion in taxes in 2010.

If the Supreme Court sided with Louisiana in saying that undocumented residents shouldn't count in divvying up Congresional districts, they may be cornered into saying the Census can't count them for other policy matters as well.

This isn't the first time Louisiana leaders have dragged the Census into the immigration debates roiling the South and country. In 2009, U.S. Sen. David Vitter (R-LA) introduced an amendment to the bill funding the 2010 Census that would have required Census workers to ask residents if they were U.S. Citizens; the senate voted down the measure.

Redistricting advocate Justin Levitt, who runs the website All About Redistricting, said on Twitter that the Louisiana suit "will lose, and lose badly, for several reasons." Rick Hasen at the University of California-Irvine agrees on the Election Law Blog:

How appealing will be an argument to a bunch of originalists/textualists that the term “persons” in the Constitution does not include all people, and in fact excludes non-legal residents?

Facing South
Facing South
Appreciate this post? Please donate & share below.
Reddit »

People Referenced:


Trade ya: You can take

Trade ya: You can take undocumented workers out of the 'person' category if you never put fetuses *in* it.

Then again, LA has rejected personhood-for-fetuses legislation, so yay. http://www.rightwingwatch.org/content/personhood-bill-flounders-louisiana


The good people of Louisiana ought to keep in mind that a good portion of their dumbasses would not be there if it were not for undocumented immigration.

Counting Immigrants

I am so tired of the double standard. Illegal immigrants are destroying this country. Some of them, especially those from south of the border are left basically alone while others are sent back...without any question. I work too hard to support a government that supports the habit of these criminals and think they should all be sent back...including those who do nothing but reproduce in order to anchor themselves here!!!

Louisiana population growth

"Thanks to the massive displacement after Hurricane Katrina -- the city of New Orleans lost 30% of its population between 2000 and 2010 -- Louisiana's delegation fell from seven seats to six.

"During the last 10 years, every other Southern state saw growth -- in many cases fueled by new immigrants."

This is technically correct, but you imply the state of Louisiana lost population as a whole. Louisiana gained population, just not enough to keep up with other states' population growth to retain the seventh seat.

Ten states lost congressional seats in 2010, but only one state actually lost population: Michigan.

Ironically, if you remove Hispanic population growth from Louisiana's numbers (driven in part by hurricane recovery jobs), then the state would have in fact netted a population loss.

Post new comment

You may enter comments here to publicly respond to this article. If you are having trouble posting your comment, please contact help@southernstudies.org.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.