A Humvee patrols outside the Superdome after Katrina. (US Army photo)
A Humvee patrols outside the Superdome after Katrina. (US Army photo)

VOICES: We got 99 problems and the Super Bowl blackout ain't one

By Rosana Cruz, Bridge the Gulf

Good natured New Orleanians may be laughing about Sunday night's blackout during the Super Bowl, as a "now you see how we live" type moment for the rest of the country.  I'm actually feeling pretty PO’ed. Not by the blackout, no. I am infuriated by the overblown language that some media makers have used to make hay over a pretty minor inconvenience, RELATIVELY SPEAKING, *ahem*. Specifically, I blew my top when Jeremy Fuchs of the Bleacher Report, referred to the 34-minute non-event as a "big disaster", and Patrick Riche of Forbes.com spoke of the challenges the city and the NFL would face in the "aftermath" of this debacle.

Wow, really?

Dang. I think New Orleans would have gotten more sensitivity and self-awareness from the Dowager Countess (for non-"Downton Abbey" fans, that's not a lot of sensitivity or awareness). Maybe the pearl clutching response would have been laughable if we in New Orleans weren't still dealing with the aftermath of some real-life big disasters, and didn't regularly see policy and budget decisions made that prioritize football over actual things that matter.

When I read Forbes contributor Patrick Rishe write, "New Orleans may need a new football stadium before they play host to their 11th Super Bowl," I remembered the meeting I was in just last week, where local residents expressed their outrage that federal Road Home dollars, which many home owners desperately needed in order to rebuild after Hurricane Katrina, were in part diverted to renovate the Superdome after the storm.

In New Orleans after the Super Bowl outage, our hotel-concierge-in-chief Mitch Landrieu issued a statement assuring out of town guests, "For us, the Super Bowl isn’t over until the last visitor leaves town, so we’re focused on continuing to show our visitors a good time.”

Please understand, out of town guests, I want you to have a good time! But we also constantly hear local and state officials telling the nation, “Your party is real important to us! New Orleans is a place to come and have a good time!” The unspoken end to that sentence is, “no matter how much pain and suffering is still happening.”

This is the same mayor who claims that the city cannot afford to fix our deadly jail. Even though nearly 30 people have died in Orleans Parish Prison since Katrina, Landrieu’s legal department is actually fighting against the push for reforms. It's even petitioning to delay implementation of the previously-lauded consent decree with the Department of Justice over the long history of abuse and corruption at the New Orleans Police Department. The mayor who wants to make sure every last Super Bowl visitor has a fun, safe time in the city says we can't afford to pay for the reforms that are needed to actually save lives.

In a city where the prison is the only accessible mental health facility for many populations, where school buildings are rotting, where all of New Orleans East is still without a hospital, forgive me if I don’t give a damn about a football game being delayed for 35 minutes. I am too busy throwing shoes at my TV as the Mayor pimps us cheap, tarting up the places that least need improvements and regulation (A "clean zone"? A new street car to the French Quarter?) for the needs of out-of-town “guests.”

It's not only the tourism industry, and it's not only in New Orleans. Louisiana Senators Mary Landrieu and David Vitter continue to push to expand oil drilling operations in the Gulf Coast, despite the disastrous impacts of the BP oil disaster, the devastating health and economic effects of which people are still suffering nearly three years later. 


This dynamic in which we service the rest of the country, regardless of the injuries of the Gulf Coast, dates back to colonial days, when the region was the place where an economy based on enslaving people made industries boom and made people rich. We see the dynamic today in how we bear the costs of producing the nation’s oil and gas on the quick and dirty, and in how private prison corporations can strike it rich caging the descendants of former slaves (many of whom also work for no pay while incarcertated). New Orleans, Louisiana, and the Gulf Coast continue to be treated like a colony.

And rather than standing up for the people they're supposed to represent, our elected officials too often facilitate the exploitation. Just last week, Louisiana Governor Bobby Jindal’s latest round of cuts eliminated health programs for low-income HIV patients, first time moms, and children. As always, these cuts target the poor, which in this world means that Black people will be disproportionately harmed. This is just the latest round of cuts in a state that says it can no longer afford public schools, hospitals, or mental health care, but continues to prioritize prisons, evidenced by the fact that this is the second largest line item in the state budget.

Meanwhile, Jindal is driving an incredibly regressive tax plan that would shift the tax burden even more heavily on poor communities, Black communities and other communities of color, by cutting income tax entirely and increasing sales tax. Corporate interests, especially the tourism and oil and gas industries, continue to be rewarded with tax breaks and lax regulations for using Louisiana as their site of doing business. We vie for industries that come here, pollute, underpay workers and don't contribute to the infrastructure that we need in order to be a thriving, functional place to live for everyone.

So when I read national commentators with no awareness of this history or sensitivity to the economics, politics, and culture of the region, suggest that New Orleans ought to spend more money on a football stadium, I get more than a little irritated.  Entertaining the N.F.L. and its fans with a seamless spectacle is just not on my list of priorities.

Image: 
A Humvee patrols outside the Superdome after Katrina. (US Army photo)
Appreciate this post? Please donate & share below.
Reddit »

Categories:

People Referenced:

Comments

super bowl in New Orleans

Right on, Ms. Cruz!

The first thing entering my mind when I learned the
Super Bowl would be played in New Orleans was, WHY?
Does this benefit the majority of the people of the City
or is it more like a tossed crumb or even a slap in the
face of those who suffered so much and continue so?
When the lights went out, I had to think, could this
be a sign of some higher power of it's displeasure at
the proceedings below?
The citizens of New Orleans endured the horror of
Katrina and the criminal negligence of the Bush
administration in providing aid and now face the
onslaught of the state and local governments in the
privatization of the public schools and a greater shift
of the tax burden to the lower classes with tax breaks
for the wealthy.
This is shameful!

Post new comment

You may enter comments here to publicly respond to this article. If you are having trouble posting your comment, please contact Jerimee@southernstudies.org.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Type the characters you see in this picture.
Type the characters you see in the picture; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated. Not case sensitive.  Switch to audio verification.